"Speak" by Laurie Halse Anderson, Reviewed by Isobella Jade

I had never read Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson, which was originally published in 1999, until a few weeks ago and now I can’t get the emotional silence of Melinda Sordino out of my head.


Sad but true, it is clear that friendship in high school relies so much on not being embarrassed or embarrassing, on wearing the right clothing and not saying the wrong thing, or not doing the wrong thing, even when someone actually did something horrifically wrong to you.


Like rape.


Melinda, who is a freshman in high school, has gone mute during a significant amount of the book as she holds in her secret of what really happened at the party in summer when she called the cops for help. When school starts she loses her circle of friends, her popularity, and her energetic self, all taken from her after that night. As she internally deals with the aftermath of what happened to her and what’s next, she also loses her love of life itself.  Although she doesn’t speak, I do find a creative symbolism in how Melinda bites her lips until they bleed and are obnoxiously chapped.


View Full Post...

Currently rated 4.3 by 3 people

  • Currently 4.333333/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Categories: Reggie Reads
Posted by Reggie on Wednesday, April 30, 2008 10:25 PM
Permalink | Comments (0) | Post RSSRSS comment feed

"Lessons From Jane Austen" by Emily Krasner

I've received many gifts in my search for my own Mr. Darcy, but when asked to recall the most meaningful and touching present I have ever received from a significant other, I need not think twice.  My Jane Austen action figure stands proudly next to my computer monitor, her brown curls mischeviously escaping her white bonnet and a 1.5 centimeter quill clutched tightly in her left hand.  Her miniature writing desk and a Polly Pocket sized copy of Pride and Prejudice lay at her feet.  (I have yet to figure out how to have her actively holding these.  As one could imagine, this is not the most high-tech action figure, and limb mobility is limited.)


And yes, I understand the irony of a quasi-immobile action figure, but I like to imagine her agility as similar to her disobedient curls – her strength not in her muscles but in the curious -- and often rebellious -- ideas that seep from beneath her bonnet.  She is my literary superheroine - witty, progressive and self sufficient. Most importantly, she is remembered as a genuine figure - like her characters, Jane refused to marry if not for love, but unlike Elizabeth, Anne, Emma, Elinor, Catherine or Fanny, she did fall victim to the conventions of her time and thus never married.


Truth be told, the entire function of Austen’s novels as parodies of 19th century courtship prohibits them from being terribly creative – the pleasure is derived from the comedy of manners that exploited what Austen deemed problematic in her time. Her heroines, typically the plainest in a family of eligible daughters in their early twenties, are all faced with the same obstacles: acquiring a husband that that will yield social advancement and monetary security without submitting to a loveless marriage. The resonance of these classic characters to contemporary characters seems almost too obvious at times. Emma is the girl who keeps herself busy meddling in our people’s relationships to avoid acknowledging her own lack of romance; while Mark Darcy is the sexy, brooding type who irritates you thoroughly before revealing his sentimental side. They are the gossip queens and prom kings of our own youth. In many ways the concept of blending backgrounds is at the forefront of Austen's texts - take the stigma adhered to the naval captains in Persuasion for example, where Admiral and Mrs. Croft have the most beautiful, symbiotic relationship of any of Austen’s characters. Captain Wentworth is considered inferior to Anne consequent to his profession, and Austen’s text points out how her contemporaries disregarded the virtue of such work in this sense. In our modern world, where job importance is often linked to monetary compensation, we can relate to how the noblest of jobs (teachers, social workers, writers) resign individuals to a lower class. Social misogeny has become even more prevalent in our generation, while interracial and interfaith marriages are now more common and accepted. Yet stigmas remain – the starving artist is romantic and desirable, but he is still starving. Austen’s tongue-in-cheek recognition of these inescapable constructs is timeless.

 

View Full Post...

Currently rated 4.8 by 6 people

  • Currently 4.833333/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Categories: Reggie Reads
Posted by Reggie on Wednesday, April 30, 2008 9:29 PM
Permalink | Comments (4) | Post RSSRSS comment feed

Reggie Reads - Something Rotten by Alan Gratz

Shakespeare never had to worry about being reviewed by zines, but today's authors of derivative works do.

 

I was really excited when I read the premise of Something Rotten by Alan Gratz -- a modern day Hamlet set in Denmark, Tennessee. Horatio Wilkes comes to stay with Hamilton Prince's family for the summer, despite the recent death of Hamilton's father and the quick remarriage of Hamilton's mother to his Uncle. When Hamilton is shown a security tape from his father's paper plant, he is convinced that his Uncle Claude is a murderer.  As they gather evidence against Claude, Hamilton and Horatio learn that going to the local police is not an option.  And when Hamilton's life is threatened, Horatio realizes he is the only one who can save his friend.

Olivia Mendelsohn, a young environmentalist, is a cool twist on Ophelia, who adds an element of romance as well as an insight into Hamilton's psyche.  While I loved the character of Olivia though, it was hard to like the character of Horatio. His internal monologue and dialogue weren't especially funny at times, and grating at worst.  At some points, it also felt like Horatio was a little too aware of his character -- almost as if Gratz's Horatio was playing a caricature of Hamlet.  Though since the other characters felt more three-dimensional, I hesitate to believe the caricature is deliberate. 

Despite the eye catching packaging and the promising premise, I would give this a 3.5 out of 5. 

Currently rated 4.0 by 1 people

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Posted by Reggie on Sunday, February 17, 2008 4:10 PM
Permalink | Comments (0) | Post RSSRSS comment feed

Reggie Reads - Someday This Pain Will Be Useful to You by Peter Cameron

People are interested in labeling James Dunfour Sveck, but James isn't at all interested in people.

James, an 18 year old Manhattanite, has been branded a possibly “disturbed” “social misfit.” Unlike the rest of his classmates, he'd rather move to his own house in the mid-west than accept his invitation to go to Brown in the fall.  And though his sister and mother are "okay" with him being gay, James isn't ready to define his sexuality.  He’s forced into therapy after an incident on an elective school trip and his mother, a future three-time divorcee, is forced to fire James from her gallery after a misguided attempt by him to attract the attention of his coworker, John Webster.

James’s only true confidant is his grandma, who doesn’t need to define James at all.

Cameron’s writing is truly amazing.  I think the way he was able to describe the paintings, The Voyage of Life by Thomas Cole, through James’s eyes really adds to the sense of futility that the James feels. 

I would say Peter Cameron's Someday This Pain Will Be Useful To You is a 4.5.

Currently rated 4.0 by 1 people

  • Currently 4/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Posted by Reggie on Friday, February 15, 2008 4:15 PM
Permalink | Comments (0) | Post RSSRSS comment feed